‘God will punish both poor and rich’: the idioms and risks of defiance in the trial of Margaretha Horn, 1652

Alison Rowlands

in Witchcraft Narratives in Germany

Published by Manchester University Press

Published in print March 2003 | ISBN: 9780719052590
Published online July 2012 | e-ISBN: 9781781700167 | DOI:
‘God will punish both poor and rich’: the idioms and risks of defiance in the trial of Margaretha Horn, 1652

More Like This

Show all results sharing this subject:

  • Early Modern History (1500 to 1700)


Show Summary Details


This chapter offers a detailed analysis of one accused witch's strategy of denying her guilt in council custody from 1652 and also shows that elite and popular attitudes towards witchcraft began to change in the course of the seventeenth century. The accused witch called Margaretha Horn not only refused to confess to witchcraft in 1652 but also developed a sophisticated rhetoric of defiance against the city council and its handling of her case in the course of her interrogation. Her trial is of such interest because it underscores particularly effectively the point that women on trial for witchcraft were not ‘mere mouthpieces of a patriarchal elite’, whose statements and confessions were simply forced rehashing of that elite's demonology. On the contrary, and despite the fact that power over the trial process lay ultimately with the council, alleged witches were capable of contributing to and of shaping the course of interrogations in idiosyncratic ways. At the same time, however, the trial of Margaretha shows that it was becoming increasingly problematic for women accused of witchcraft in early modern Rothenburg to articulate defiance against their accusers and the council without this defiance being interpreted as additional evidence of their alleged identity as witches.

Keywords: patriachal elite; witch's strategy; Margaretha Horn; witchcraft; demonology; interrogation; city council

Chapter.  13289 words. 

Subjects: Early Modern History (1500 to 1700)

Full text: subscription required

How to subscribe Recommend to my Librarian

Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content. Please, subscribe or login to access all content.