Geoffrey Hill: A ‘Question of Value’

David‐Antoine Williams

in Defending Poetry

Published in print September 2010 | ISBN: 9780199583546
Published online May 2011 | e-ISBN: 9780191595295 | DOI:

Series: Oxford English Monographs

Geoffrey Hill: A ‘Question of Value’

Show Summary Details


This chapter investigates Geoffrey Hill's abiding concern with the equation of semantic and ethical recognition, his experience of language as an arena in which our ethical being is both menaced and succoured, though perhaps not secured. Hill's cogitations on this problem accompany a career‐long exploration of the question of intrinsic value, a concept which he admits has gone out of fashion but which he nonetheless attempts to rescue for his theory of language. Hill's ethics of responsibility requires that literature memorialize and memorize the dead, but his scepticism about the ability of language to do justice to its subjects forces him into a paradoxical contemplation of silence as the only responsible speech. Even so, the question of value has increasingly been posed by Hill in its public dimension, as embodying the union of civic (including political), theological (including metaphysical), and grammatical (including etymological) thought. One way Hill thinks the writer can realize intrinsic value is in the assiduous plying of words, the working in poetry of their etymology, grammar, and syntax into a high semantic pitch; this chapter pays special attention to the words that have meant the most to Hill: ‘value’, ‘atonement’, ‘endurance’, ‘patience’, ‘attention’, ‘justice’, ‘grace’, ‘pitch’, ‘common’, and ‘alienation’.

Keywords: Hill; Hopkins; Whitman; Eliot; intrinsic value; original sin; atonement; difficulty; responsibility; endurance; alienation; silence; suffering; memory; memorial; etymology; pitch; Holocaust; Steiner; Ricoeur; Adorno

Chapter.  255 words. 

Subjects: Literary Studies (Poetry and Poets)

Full text: subscription required

How to subscribe Recommend to my Librarian

Buy this work at Oxford University Press »

Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content. Please, subscribe or login to access all content.