The Creator and Evil

Brian Davies

in Thomas Aquinas on God and Evil

Published in print August 2011 | ISBN: 9780199790890
Published online September 2011 | e-ISBN: 9780199914418 | DOI:
The Creator and Evil

Show Summary Details


This chapter explores the topic of God and causation. If God is the Creator in Aquinas's sense, must he not be causally responsible for evil or badness in any form? And if God is this, can anything be salvaged of the claim that God is good? Given what is discussed in the previous chapter, you might imagine Aquinas replying, “Well, God's goodness is not moral goodness, so even his causing of what is bad does not tell against it.” But he did not take this line. He seemed to think that directly to will evil as an end in itself is indicative of badness, for he often said that what is good (or goodness in general) produces only what is good. And, when it comes to creation and God's causing of evil or badness, the approach he adopted is simply to deny that God causes evil directly and as an end in itself. Philosophers other than Aquinas have defended this way of thinking by arguing that much that is evil or bad should be thought of as a necessary means to goods aimed at by God. The idea here is that God wants to produce certain goods, but cannot do so without also permitting certain evils, and there is a sense in which Aquinas did buy into this argument. He did not do so, however, insofar as the argument is construed as suggesting that God's creating what is good ever involved him in having to put up with there being evil. This is perhaps best understood by noting what Aquinas took God's omnipotence to involve.

Keywords: Thomas Aquinas; God; omnipotence; goodness; evil

Chapter.  6850 words. 

Subjects: Philosophy of Religion

Full text: subscription required

How to subscribe Recommend to my Librarian

Buy this work at Oxford University Press »

Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content. Please, subscribe or login to access all content.