Opening, Closing, and Moving through Interpretive Disputes

Martin Camper

in Arguing over Texts

Published in print December 2017 | ISBN: 9780190677121
Published online November 2017 | e-ISBN: 9780190677152 | DOI:
Opening, Closing, and Moving through Interpretive Disputes

Show Summary Details


Chapter 8 explores how the interpretive stases are logically related to each other and how interpretive disputes are initiated and resolved. The chapter explains how the interpretive stases occur in a predictable, presuppositional sequence in which certain interpretive issues must be resolved or settled before further interpretive issues can be considered. The chapter also discusses what happens when additional passages or texts are brought in to support an argument about another passage or text. Passages from Margaret Fell’s seventeenth-century pamphlet arguing for women’s right to preach illustrate these points. Building on Patricia Roberts-Miller’s framework for understanding deliberative conflicts, the chapter outlines four different types of interpretive communities based on their valuation and use of disagreement and interpretive argument. Each of these types of communities initiates and resolves interpretive disputes in different ways. The chapter also describes three constraining factors that influence the felt need to resolve an interpretive disagreement.

Keywords: deliberative conflict; dispute; interpretive community; Margaret Fell; Patricia Roberts-Miller; presupposition; women’s preaching

Chapter.  4753 words. 

Subjects: Psycholinguistics

Full text: subscription required

How to subscribe Recommend to my Librarian

Buy this work at Oxford University Press »

Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content. Please, subscribe or login to access all content. subscribe or login to access all content.